Real Matcha in New Orleans

A coffee shop owner's honest take

Where to Find Real Matcha in New Orleans

Most matcha in this city is bad. I want to start there because it's the part nobody at a coffee shop will tell you to your face. The matcha latte you ordered last week — the one that tasted vaguely grassy, slightly bitter, the color of pond scum — that wasn't a matcha latte. That was milk with green powder in it.

I run Witches Brew on Canal Street, and matcha is one of the things we pour the most of, which means I spend a lot of time thinking about matcha, ordering matcha, drinking matcha I didn't make, and trying to figure out why so much of what's sold in New Orleans is so disappointing.

Here's what I've learned.

I
What good matcha actually tastes like

First sip is smooth. There's a slight sweetness on the front of the tongue, a vegetal finish like new spring leaves, no bitterness at the back of the throat. The color in the cup should be the green of cut grass in May, not the color of dried oregano. If you've only ever had matcha that tastes like hay, you've never actually had matcha.

II
Why most of it in New Orleans is bad

Real single-origin matcha is expensive — multiples of what bulk culinary-grade powder costs. The math is what it is. Shops that charge bargain prices for a matcha latte are making one of three choices: they're losing money on every cup, they're underdosing the powder, or they're using the cheap stuff.

A lot of places make the third choice. I won't name names because the New Orleans coffee scene is small and I have to keep ordering from the same supply reps. But the cup tells you. Trust the cup.

III
The “ceremonial grade” question

You'll see “ceremonial grade” on a lot of matcha packaging. The honest answer is that the grade names aren't standardized. There's no Japanese trade authority labeling matcha “ceremonial” versus “culinary” — it's marketing language used inconsistently by importers and cafés.

What actually matters is whether the matcha was grown for drinking straight (shade-grown for the last three weeks before harvest, hand-picked from the first spring picking, stone-milled slowly) or grown for baking and blending (later harvests, machine-milled, intentionally robust enough to push through chocolate cake or a smoothie).

If you're ordering a matcha latte, you want the first kind. Most shops will use the second kind to save money and most customers won't be able to tell because the milk and sweetener cover everything. That's a self-fulfilling problem and it's most of why matcha in this country tastes wrong.

IV
What we pour

We use Mizuba Tea Co. matcha from Yame, Japan, on draft. Mizuba sources from a single farm, stone-milled, harvested from the first spring picking. Most of what leaves the bar is on draft — nitro-pulled matcha latte, which is its own format. It's not what you'd find in Kyoto. It is the same powder Kyoto serves. For our coffee program more broadly, see our coffee writeup.

Two drinks I'd point a matcha newcomer toward, in order:

Rose Garden Ritual

Iced Matcha Latte · rose + vanilla + cold foam

It's our most-ordered matcha latte and the easiest entry point. The rose tempers the powder enough to ease you in without hiding it.

Straight Matcha

Just the matcha & the water it was whisked into

The way you actually find out whether a shop is doing it right.

V
How to order matcha at any shop in town

Three rules.

Order it iced first.

Bad matcha hides better in steam and warm milk. A bad iced matcha latte tastes worse than a bad hot one, which is useful — you'll know quickly whether to come back.

Ask what they use.

A barista who can name the brand and the origin is at a shop that's thinking about it. A barista who shrugs is at a shop that isn't.

Look at the color in the cup.

Bright forest green = real. Dull army green = filler. Pond brown = walk away.

I'd rather pay more, once, for matcha that's actually matcha than less, three times a week, for green-tinted milk.

VI
What real matcha costs and why it's worth it

Our matcha drinks cost more than the cheap-powder versions at the chain shops, and I sleep fine with that. The math on what you're getting per dollar is different than the math on price. A real matcha latte from a shop that bought the right powder, dosed it correctly, and pulled it with intent is a different drink than the powder-and-milk version. After you've had a few of each you stop being willing to spend less on the wrong one.

Come try ours. Try the next place's. You'll be able to tell the difference within two sips. The good shops in this city know who they are, and so will you.

Try ours

We pour Mizuba single-origin matcha on draft. Order the Rose Garden Ritual to start, or ask for a straight 6-oz bowl.

Witches Brew Coffee Co. · 2940 Canal St, Mid-City · Open Daily 8 AM – 6 PM